Archives
May 15, 2008
Who Will Be The Hawks New GM?

May 7, 2008
Goodbye B.K.

May 5, 2008
The Hawks Are Back On The Scene

Apr 18, 2008
Hawks Ascend Into Postseason Action

Mar 14, 2008
Horford Steals The Spotlight

Full Archive

Childress And Smith Make All-Rookie Team
Authored by Patrick J. Austin - May 6, 2005 - 12:37 pm


Current Featured Columns
Comparing The Age Of The Spurs To Previous Dynasties
Are there any indicators that can be taken from the end of previous dynasties that suggest the Spurs' run is over?

Auditing The Knicks 2007-08 Season
The Knicks once again followed their tried and true formula of poor defense, one-dimensional players and a grossly overpaid team.

Lottery Summit: Charlotte Bobcats
The Bobcats have a ton of youth, leading many fans to dream of yet another draft night trade.
Lottery Summit: Milwaukee Bucks
GM John Hammond has given Milwaukee fans some confidence heading into the offseason.
Auditing The Blazers 2007-08 Season
A young, talented, and hard-working .500 team will naturally upgrade themselves with the additions of Oden, Rudy, and a lottery pick.
More from RealGM's Columnists

RealGM Search
Search:
I’d like to give major props to our dynamic duo of Josh Childress and Josh Smith for making the All-Rookie second team. The development of Chill and Smoove has been fun to watch. Both began the season on the bench, but through hard work and maturation ended the season in the starting rotation playing major roles.

Many, including myself, believe they should have been on the All-Rookie first team. The only players who earned a definite spot on the first team were Ben Gordon, Emeka Okafor, and Dwight Howard. The other two, Andre Iguoldala and Luol Deng, could have easily been replaced by Chill and Smoove. In fact, if you compare the stats of Childress and Iguoldala, Chill had better season averages.

When comparing Deng and Smith, Deng had better numbers at the beginning of the year but regressed after the all-star break and then missed most the second half due to an injury. Meanwhile, Smith became the reason to watch Hawks games. His acrobatic dunks and surprising defensive intensity (ten blocks in a game) have made him the face of the franchise.

I’m not trying to say Deng and Iggy didn’t deserve to make the team, but it’s obvious they were placed on first string due to their respective clubs making the postseason, not because of their individual performance.

Between Childress and Smith, I believe Childress deserves a little more praise. Virtually everyone criticized the Hawks for taking him so high (sixth pick). At the beginning of the year, the criticism was valid. He didn’t look like that poised, college-experienced wingman we were all expecting. He seemed timid and even lost during periods of a game. Though, right around mid-season, that strange shot of his started to fall and he was routinely scoring in double-digits while pulling down an impressive number of rebounds (for a shooting guard). It’s safe to say he silenced those critics and secured the starting two-guard position for the foreseeable future (that is, if we don’t sign someone like Larry Hughes or Joe Johnson via free agency).

What can I say about Josh Smith that hasn’t already been said? The kid has brought hope to a franchise in desperate need of it. He still has a long way to go in terms of learning the nuances of the game, but you can see a star in the making.

Hawks fans should be excited about these two rooks. They’re a part of our foundation and I expect both to make a major impact on this franchise for many years to come.